API Monitoring Tools Compared: The Honest Developer's Guide (2026)

API Monitoring Tools Compared: The Honest Developer's Guide (2026)

Let's cut through the marketing BS. You need to monitor APIs. Here's what's actually good (and what's not) across the landscape of API monitoring tools in 2026.

I'll tell you when competitors beat us. I'll tell you where we win. You decide.

Quick Comparison Table

Tool Best For Starting Price Free Tier Real Endpoint Testing
API Status Check Developers, real-time monitoring Free ✅ 120+ APIs ✅ Yes
Downdetector Quick outage checks Free ✅ Always free ❌ Crowdsourced
StatusGator Enterprise aggregation $29/mo ❌ No ❌ Status scraping
IsDown Simple dashboard $18/mo (was $9) ❌ No ❌ Status scraping
UptimeRobot Website uptime Free ✅ 50 monitors ✅ Yes
Better Stack Incident management $29/mo ✅ 1 project ✅ Yes
Checkly Synthetic monitoring $7/mo ✅ 10k runs ✅ Yes

1. API Status Check (Us) — Free Real-Time API Monitoring

What we do: Monitor 120+ APIs in real-time with actual endpoint testing. Free forever for developers.

Pricing: Free (no catch, no credit card)

What we're best at:

  • Zero config — Sign up, get instant status for GitHub, Stripe, OpenAI, AWS, etc.
  • Real endpoint testing — We hit actual API endpoints every 60 seconds
  • Developer-first — Clean API, webhooks, MCP server for Claude Desktop
  • Always free — No "14-day trial" nonsense

Where competitors win:

  • Coverage: Downdetector has 30,000+ services (we have 120+ APIs)
  • Enterprise features: StatusGator has better compliance reporting
  • Synthetic monitoring: Checkly has full browser automation
  • Incident management: Better Stack has superior on-call workflows

Who should use us:

  • Developers building on popular APIs
  • Teams monitoring SaaS dependencies (Stripe, GitHub, Auth0)
  • Anyone who wants instant monitoring without config hell

Try API Status Check →

3. StatusGator — Enterprise Status Aggregator

What they do: Aggregate status pages from 2,400+ services. Fancy dashboards, compliance reports, Slack notifications.

Pricing: $29-399/mo (no free tier)

What they're best at:

  • Enterprise features — Compliance reports, audit logs, SSO
  • Broad coverage — 2,400+ services monitored
  • Custom branding — White-label status pages
  • Slack/Teams integration — Native bots with rich formatting

Where they fall short:

  • Status page scraping — Not real endpoint testing (delayed, unreliable)
  • Expensive — $29/mo minimum ($348/year)
  • Overkill for small teams — Enterprise features most devs don't need
  • No free tier — Can't try before you buy (14-day trial only)

Who should use them:

  • Large enterprises needing compliance/audit trails
  • Teams with budget for premium features
  • Companies requiring white-label status pages

Looking for an enterprise status aggregation platform? Read our API Status Check vs StatusGator comparison for a detailed feature breakdown.

4. IsDown — Simple Dashboard (Price Hiking Feb 16)

What they do: Clean dashboard showing status for 5,450+ services. Status page scraping.

Pricing: $18/mo (was $9/mo until Feb 16, 2026 price hike)

What they're best at:

  • Clean UI — Best-looking dashboard in the space
  • Broad coverage — 5,450+ services
  • Mobile app — iOS/Android apps (rare in this category)
  • Notification customization — Granular filtering

Where they fall short:

  • 22-33% price increase — $9 → $12 (Starter), $15 → $18 (Premium), $27 → $36 (Business)
  • Status page scraping — Not real endpoint testing
  • No free tier — Can't monitor anything without paying
  • Value proposition unclear — What justifies the price vs free alternatives?

Who should use them:

  • Teams who value UI/UX over cost
  • Mobile-first users needing apps
  • Existing users grandfathered into old pricing

Migration guide: IsDown alternatives after the price hike

5. UptimeRobot — Classic Uptime Monitoring

What they do: Website and API uptime monitoring. Ping URLs, check HTTP status, alert on downtime.

Pricing: Free (50 monitors), $7/mo (Pro)

What they're best at:

  • Price — Free tier is generous (50 monitors, 5-min checks)
  • Uptime reports — Public status pages included
  • Flexibility — Monitor anything with a URL
  • Longevity — Been around since 2010, stable product

Where they fall short:

  • Manual config — You must add URLs manually (no "just works" for popular APIs)
  • Generic monitoring — Not API-specific (you get HTTP 200/500, not API-specific issues)
  • 5-minute checks — Free tier only checks every 5 mins (vs our 60-second checks)
  • Different category — Uptime monitoring ≠ API status monitoring

Who should use them:

  • Teams monitoring custom/internal APIs
  • Website uptime monitoring
  • Anyone needing flexible, configurable monitoring

Note: UptimeRobot and API Status Check solve different problems. UptimeRobot is for monitoring your APIs. We monitor third-party SaaS APIs.

6. Better Stack — Incident Management + Monitoring

What they do: Full incident management suite. Monitoring, alerting, on-call schedules, status pages, incident retrospectives.

Pricing: $29/mo (Startup), $79/mo (Team), $149/mo (Business)

What they're best at:

  • Incident management — Best on-call workflows, escalation policies
  • Status pages — Beautiful, customizable status pages
  • Unified platform — Monitoring + alerting + incidents in one tool
  • Modern UX — Clean, fast interface

Where they fall short:

  • Overkill for simple monitoring — You're paying for features you may not need
  • Expensive — $29/mo minimum ($348/year)
  • Manual setup required — Not "zero config" like API Status Check
  • Startup focus — Great if you're building SaaS, not if you're just consuming APIs

Who should use them:

  • SaaS companies building public status pages
  • Teams with on-call rotations needing incident management
  • Companies wanting all-in-one solution (monitoring + alerting + incidents)

API Status Check vs Better Stack: We complement each other. Use Better Stack for your infrastructure incidents, use us to monitor third-party API dependencies.

7. Checkly — Synthetic Monitoring for Developers

What they do: Synthetic monitoring with full browser automation. Monitor APIs, websites, and user flows with code.

Pricing: $7/mo (Starter), $79/mo (Team), $299/mo (Enterprise)

What they're best at:

  • Developer-first — Write monitors as code (JavaScript/TypeScript)
  • Browser automation — Full Playwright integration for UI testing
  • CI/CD integration — Run checks in your deploy pipeline
  • API + Browser — Monitor both APIs and frontend flows

Where they fall short:

  • Manual config — You write the monitoring code (not "just works")
  • Learning curve — Requires coding, not point-and-click
  • Run-based pricing — 10k runs/month free, then pay per check
  • Different use case — Synthetic monitoring ≠ real-time status monitoring

Who should use them:

  • Developers monitoring critical user flows (login, checkout, signup)
  • Teams running synthetic tests in CI/CD
  • Companies needing browser-based monitoring

API Status Check vs Checkly: Different categories. Checkly is for monitoring your app's user flows. We monitor third-party APIs in real-time.

The Honest Truth: What You Actually Need

If you're a developer monitoring third-party APIs:

Use API Status Check. It's free, works instantly, and monitors the APIs you actually use (GitHub, Stripe, OpenAI, AWS).

If you're an enterprise with compliance requirements:

Use StatusGator. Yes, it's expensive ($29-399/mo). But you need the audit logs, SSO, and compliance reports.

If you need incident management + monitoring:

Use Better Stack. It's the best all-in-one platform for SaaS companies. Worth the $29/mo.

If you're monitoring your own infrastructure:

Use UptimeRobot (free tier) or Checkly (if you want synthetic monitoring). These are for monitoring your APIs, not third-party dependencies.

If you just want to check "is X down?" manually:

Use Downdetector. It's free, crowdsourced, and has 30,000+ services. Just don't expect real-time accuracy or API access.

If you value UI/UX above all else and have budget:

Use IsDown. It's the prettiest dashboard. But at $18/mo (after the Feb 16 price hike), you're paying a premium for aesthetics.

Pricing Reality Check

Let's be real about cost:

Tool Annual Cost What You Get
API Status Check $0 120+ APIs, real-time monitoring, webhooks, API access
Downdetector $0 30,000+ services, crowdsourced, ads
UptimeRobot $0-84 50 monitors free, 5-min checks
Checkly $84+ 10k runs/mo, synthetic monitoring
IsDown $216 5,450+ services, mobile apps, clean UI
Better Stack $348+ Incident management, on-call, status pages
StatusGator $348-4,788 2,400+ services, enterprise features

Bottom line: If you're just monitoring third-party API dependencies, you probably don't need to spend $200-500/year. The free tools (API Status Check, Downdetector, UptimeRobot free tier) cover 90% of use cases.

Feature Comparison: What Actually Matters

Real Endpoint Testing vs Status Page Scraping

Real endpoint testing (API Status Check, UptimeRobot, Checkly, Better Stack):

  • ✅ Tests actual API availability
  • ✅ Detects issues before status pages update
  • ✅ Measures real response times

Status page scraping (StatusGator, IsDown):

  • ❌ Relies on vendor reporting (5-30 min delay)
  • ❌ Misses unreported partial outages
  • ❌ No actual endpoint testing

Crowdsourced (Downdetector):

  • ✅ Detects widespread issues quickly
  • ❌ 5-15 min lag (users must report first)
  • ❌ False positives from user error

Verdict: Real endpoint testing wins. Status page scraping is fundamentally delayed and unreliable.

API Access

Tool API Access Webhooks Integrations
API Status Check ✅ REST API ✅ Yes Slack, Discord, MCP
StatusGator ✅ REST API ✅ Yes Slack, Teams, email
Better Stack ✅ REST API ✅ Yes Everything
UptimeRobot ✅ REST API ✅ Yes Many
Checkly ✅ REST API ✅ Yes CI/CD, Slack
IsDown ❌ No API ⚠️ Limited Mobile apps
Downdetector ❌ No API ❌ No None

Verdict: If you need automation (Slack alerts, PagerDuty integration, custom dashboards), IsDown and Downdetector are non-starters.

Coverage: Breadth vs Depth

Broad coverage (many services):

  • Downdetector: 30,000+ services
  • IsDown: 5,450+ services
  • StatusGator: 2,400+ services

Deep coverage (fewer services, better monitoring):

  • API Status Check: 120+ APIs (real endpoint testing)
  • UptimeRobot: Unlimited (you configure)
  • Checkly: Unlimited (you code)
  • Better Stack: Unlimited (you configure)

Verdict: Depends on your needs. If you use popular APIs (GitHub, Stripe, AWS), deep coverage wins. If you need obscure SaaS tools, go broad.

The "Just Use Multiple Tools" Strategy

Here's what smart teams actually do:

  1. API Status Check (free) — Monitor popular APIs you depend on
  2. Downdetector (free) — Quick manual checks for outages
  3. UptimeRobot (free tier) — Monitor your own internal APIs
  4. Better Stack or PagerDuty (paid) — If you need incident management

Total cost: $0-29/mo depending on incident management needs.

You don't need to pick one tool. Use the free ones together.

FAQ

What's the difference between API monitoring and uptime monitoring?

Uptime monitoring (UptimeRobot, Pingdom):

  • Monitor your infrastructure
  • Ping URLs, check HTTP status
  • Generic (works for any URL)

API monitoring (API Status Check):

  • Monitor third-party SaaS APIs
  • Pre-configured for popular services
  • API-specific (knows what endpoints to test)

Should I pay for API monitoring?

If you're a small team/solo dev: Probably not. Free tools (API Status Check, Downdetector, UptimeRobot) cover most needs.

If you're an enterprise: Maybe. StatusGator ($29-399/mo) or Better Stack ($29+/mo) offer compliance, audit logs, and white-label features.

Why is IsDown raising prices?

No official reason given. The Feb 16, 2026 price hike (22-33% increase) suggests either rising costs or testing price elasticity. Either way, at $18/mo it's now competing with Better Stack ($29/mo) which offers way more features.

Migration guide if you're leaving IsDown →

Which tool has the best API?

Better Stack — Most comprehensive API, best docs.

API Status Check — Simplest API, easiest to integrate.

StatusGator — Good API, enterprise focus.

Can I monitor custom/internal APIs with API Status Check?

Not yet. We focus on popular third-party APIs (GitHub, Stripe, AWS, etc.). For custom APIs, use UptimeRobot or Better Stack.

Which tool is best for monitoring Stripe, GitHub, OpenAI?

API Status Check. We have real endpoint testing for all three, free forever, zero config.

Conclusion: Pick the Right Tool for Your Needs

Don't overthink this:

  • Free monitoring of popular APIs? → API Status Check
  • Quick manual outage checks? → Downdetector
  • Enterprise compliance? → StatusGator
  • Incident management? → Better Stack
  • Monitor your own APIs? → UptimeRobot or Checkly
  • Prettiest UI, have budget? → IsDown (but $18/mo is steep)

Most developers should start with the free tools (API Status Check + Downdetector) and only upgrade to paid tools when they hit specific limitations.

Start monitoring APIs for free →

Related guides:

Monitor Your APIs

Check the real-time status of 100+ popular APIs used by developers.

View API Status →